Offshore drilling: “systemic” safety problems?

Drilling rig, Port of Takoradi, Ghana. Photo by Christiane Badgley

How safe are Ghana’s offshore oil drilling operations?  According to officials I’ve interviewed here so far, Ghana’s oil operations are safe, secure and pose no particular threats to people or the environment. An EPA official in Takoradi assured me that the waters off the coast of Ghana are much calmer than those in the Gulf of Mexico. He also reminded me that the Deepwater Horizon spill was due to human error and that Ghana is constantly verifying every aspect of the oil operations in order to avoid any mistakes. Spin. Of course. After all, what are officials going to tell me? That they’re worried?

I’m going to write more about the specific risks in Ghana, as well as the country’s environmental regulation and oversight, but first I want to post an article from Oil and Gas Journal about offshore drilling safety in general. Are there systemic safety problems associated with deep water offshore drilling, or  was the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill an avoidable accident?

Views differ over ‘systemic’ problem

Mar 9, 2011

By OGJ editor

HOUSTON, Mar. 9 — Differing perspectives on allegations about “systemic” safety problems in offshore oil and gas work emerged during a session panel session on deepwater operations at the IHS-CERA energy conference in Houston.

William Reilly, co-chairman of the US National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and Offshore Drilling, defended the characterization, which appeared in the commission’s report to President Barack Obama in January an drew criticism from industry groups.

The Apr. 20, 2010, accident, which killed 11 workers, showed the industry lacked the ability to contain a deepwater spill, had provided assurance to the contrary in “pro forma response plans,” and hadn’t modernized spill-cleanup equipment, Reilly said. And the commission report found lapses not only by BP, the well operator, but also by Halliburton, which performed the cement job, and Transocean, which owned the rig.

“There’s plenty of evidence that it was a systemic problem,” said Reilly, a former administrator of the US Environmental Protection Agency who said he has investments in and sits on the boards of oil and gas companies.

Ali Moshiri, president of Chevron Africa & Latin America E&P Co., said the Gulf of Mexico problem “was not a systematic problem. It was an accident that never should have happened.”

Reilly applauded the industry’s rapid development of spill-containment capability through the Marine Well Containment Co. and Helix Well Containment Group and said, “Major obstacles to renewing drilling have been removed.”

Alluding to a strong message in the commission report, he said, “A renewed culture of safety does seem to be emerging.”

Reilly also acknowledged the need for oil and gas from deep water but warned of the consequent “migration toward risk.”

Of the need for development of challenging resources, Moshiri said, “We have to be in the deep water because the era of easy oil is over, and demand continues to grow.”

The Chevron executive said companies apply the best safety and technical standards they can.

“Safety and environmental protection is not a cost,” he said. “It’s part of the value that you create.”


The key phrase here is the “migration toward risk.” Lessons were learned from the Deepwater Horizon spill, certainly, but new drilling in uncharted waters is inherently risky.

Comments are closed.

Increase your website traffic with